English 
简体中文 
日本語 
香港中文 
Français 
Español 
Bahasa Indonesia 
한국어 
The Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) has created a seismic shift in the way financial markets approach sustainability. At its core, the regulation seeks to enhance transparency in how financial market participants integrate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors into their investment decisions.
A pivotal element within this regulation is the Principle Adverse Impact (PAI) Statement, a disclosure mechanism designed to highlight the negative sustainability impacts of investment decisions. Since June 30 June 2021, larger firms with over 500 employees have been mandated to disclose their consideration of Principal Adverse Impacts (PAIs), with the reporting of these impacts expected to start in mid-2023 for data gathered throughout 2022. From 1 January 2023, asset managers are required to provide more detailed and quantifiable information on how they consider PAIs, including specific indicators related to climate, environment, social and employee matters, human rights, and anti-corruption and anti-bribery issues [1].
As the demand for PAI statements grows, comprehending the extensive impact of these regulations on the financial sector and beyond becomes crucial. Therefore, our blog aims to provide an extensive guide to understanding PAI statements.
Understanding PAI Statements
The EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) aims to enhance sustainability within the financial sector by promoting transparency and introducing standardized disclosures. Under these new regulations, asset managers and financial advisers are obliged to disclose how they integrate Sustainability Risks and consider the Principal Adverse Impacts (PAIs) of their investment decisions or advice on sustainability factors. This requirement mandates disclosures at both the organizational and product levels for asset managers, while advisers must detail their consideration of these factors in their advisory services.
PAI statement is an integral part of the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR), mandating asset managers and financial advisers to detail the Principal Adverse Impacts (PAIs) of their investment decisions or advice on sustainability factors. This focuses on ensuring that investments do not negatively affect sustainability goals, requiring disclosures that highlight how sustainability risks are considered and managed within investment strategies and advisory services. PAIs refer to the negative consequences that investment decisions or advice may have on environmental and social factors. Examples include investments in companies engaged in practices that significantly increase carbon dioxide emissions or those with inadequate management of water resources, waste, or land. The regulation emphasizes the importance of understanding and mitigating these adverse impacts, pushing for a more conscious approach to investment and advisory practices within the financial industry.
Why PAI Matters More Than Ever
The essence of disclosing PAI lies in its ability to build investor trust and foster a more sustainable investment environment. Unlike other reports focused on financial performance, PAI Statements dig deeper into how financial activities contribute to or detract from sustainability objectives. This unique focus on adverse impacts sets PAI apart, pushing it to the forefront of sustainable investment frameworks. Rather than solely relying on positive environmental, social and governance (ESG) metrics, PAIs highlight the potential damage that certain investments can cause to sustainability goals. This allows investors to make more informed decisions that align with their values and sustainability objectives.
Moreover, the mandatory disclosures of PAI Statements also serve as an accountability mechanism for financial market participants. It shines a spotlight on how these institutions are incorporating sustainability factors into their decision-making process, creating a level of transparency that was previously lacking. By holding them accountable for considering and mitigating PAIs, the SFDR aims to drive change within the financial industry towards more sustainable practices.
Required Actions for Crafting a PAI Statement
Crafting a PAI Statement involves a series of steps, beginning with identifying adverse sustainability impacts relevant to the investment entities and products. The framework mandates both entity-level and product-level disclosures, ensuring that investors have a comprehensive understanding of how their financial choices affect ESG factors.
On an Entity Level
On an entity level, the Principal Adverse Impact (PAI) statement is a crucial annual disclosure by financial entities, outlining how they integrate considerations of adverse impacts on sustainability into their investment decisions. This statement is obligatory for financial market participants with 500 or more employees for the reported financial year.
Entities with fewer employees face a “comply or explain” mandate, where those incorporating PAI in their investment strategies must detail their approach in the PAI statement. Conversely, entities not considering PAIs must clarify their reasons.
The SFDR Delegated Regulation annex offers a PAI statement template, guiding entities through the process. This template encompasses descriptions of identified adverse sustainability indicators (PAIs), relevant PAI indicators, shareholder engagement policies, and comparisons to previous years, adhering to the SFDR Delegated Regulation’s requirements.
The PAI description should include metrics used, impact assessments, rationale, and actions taken or planned for each identified adverse sustainability indicator. PAI indicators span environmental, social, and governance (ESG) risks, with special attention to climate and environmental issues, as well as considerations regarding employees, human rights, anti-corruption, and anti-bribery policies.
On a Product Level
Product-level disclosures delve deeper by giving precise information on the incorporation of sustainability impacts into investment choices and evaluating the potential effects on sustainability factors.
Furthermore, financial market participants must disclose PAI at the product level, going beyond the annual PAI statement to ensure transparency. This requirement does not extend to financial advisors.
For entities with 500 or more employees, adherence is obligatory, while others may opt for the “comply or explain” approach. [2]
If a financial product does not consider PAI related to sustainability factors, its pre-contractual documentation must clearly state this, including the reasons for not considering them. Conversely, if PAI on sustainability factors are taken into account, the pre-contractual disclosures must thoroughly detail how this is achieved. Essentially, the SFDR mandates that the pre-contractual information must provide:
A clear and reasoned statement on whether, and if so, how the financial product considers PAI on sustainability factors; and an assurance that details on the PAI on sustainability factors will be included in periodic or annual reports.
Challenges in Implementing PAI Statements
Although the purpose of PAI Statements is admirable, financial market participants might encounter several obstacles during implementation. Challenges include the absence of uniform metrics and methodologies for gauging negative sustainability impacts. Without a definitive framework, organizations could find it difficult to pinpoint pertinent indicators and precisely evaluate their effects.
In addition, there may be discrepancies in definitions of sustainability risks and PAIs across regions, making it challenging for global entities to comply with regulations consistently.
Furthermore, the “comply or explain” approach may lead to inconsistent and potentially vague explanations for not considering PAI. This could make it difficult for investors to accurately compare entities and products.
Final Thoughts
In today’s investment landscape, PAI Statements are more than just regulatory compliance; they represent a commitment to sustainable finance and a step towards a more responsible future. By effectively disclosing the principle adverse impacts of investment decisions, entities can drive the shift towards more sustainable financial markets and contribute to achieving global sustainability goals.
The SFDR and PAI Statements are pivotal in this transition, providing a framework for transparency, accountability, and sustained action. For sustainable investors, financial advisors, and ESG enthusiasts, understanding and implementing these disclosures is not only an obligation but an opportunity to lead the way in sustainable finance.
Whether you are at the beginning of your sustainable finance journey or looking to deepen your ESG impact, the time to act is now. The path to a sustainable future is through informed decisions, transparency, and continuous engagement with sustainability goals. Navigate the waters of PAI Statements with care, and you’ll contribute to steering the financial sector towards a greener, more resilient tomorrow.
In unlocking the full potential of PAI Statements and SFDR Disclosure, we can collectively work towards achieving a sustainable finance ecosystem that benefits not just today’s investors but future generations as well.
Sources:
[2] https://www2.deloitte.com/nl/nl/pages/legal/articles/pai-disclosures-under-the-sfdr.html
